liam gallagher is one of the best live singers of all time. certainly one of the best i've ever heard.

this stuff about Brown not being able to sing properly, was just a roses myth i thought ? like there last run of shows they'd totally lost interest and were all shite . i thought that was the case anyway, im no expert. i thought he'd gone on to prove himself when he went solo.

whats weather forecast ?

Ive seen Browner three times now and each time he has been spot on particularly the last time when he played all the Roses stuff. He can sing. Whoever is goin tonight is in for a treat.

this stuff about Brown not being able to sing properly, was just a roses myth i thought ?

Dunno, I remember reading that in the days before Autotune it used to take the producers 30-40 takes of him singing to be able to stitch together a vocal that was good enough to lay down with the rest of the track. No idea where I read it though so it could be bollox.

i've seen him live and from watching videos etc of both solo and roses stuff he as very best perfunctory. ffs, its not like stone roses songs are remotely hard to sing!

Also, magoo, whatever about oasis Liam Gallagher has a very strong live vocal, Brown is an amatuer in comparison.

agreed - one thing i loved about the roses was we could all sing the tunes on the bus home from the big dish go !

At least Brown has originality. Liam Gallagher built his whole vocal style around Ten Story Love Song if you ask me.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0uNLw3pXlVM

Too early for reports?